Aviation Official Says State Case Over Avgas Ban Would Devastate Industry
By Sean Belk - Staff Writer
January 31, 2012 - Legal action initiated in state court last year, aimed at prodding the end of leaded aviation fuel by aircraft users due to the potential health risks to residents near airports, may devastate aviation business in California, and eventually the country, according aviation business advocates.
The Center for Environmental Health (CEH), a non-profit environmental justice advocacy group, filed a preliminary lawsuit in May 2011, claiming that the suppliers and producers of 100-low-lead, or avgas, fuel used by piston-engine airplanes, primarily classified as general aviation aircraft, have violated California law for not warning the public about lead exposure.
Under California’s Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act, known as Proposition 65, established in 1986, residents near sources of high lead emissions must be notified of the potential for lead exposures, while lead found in drinking water above legal limits is prohibited.
Only piston-engine aircraft, including small airplanes and some helicopters, are federally permitted to use avgas, which includes lead additives. Jet-powered airplanes, such as corporate jets, currently use jet fuel, which contains no lead. Although federal efforts are underway to formulate an alternative, the CEH has brought the case forward at the state level, mainly to spur the eventual elimination of lead in avgas and to reduce air pollution throughout the nation, according to CEH officials.
The suit against five oil companies and 38 aviation fuel retail businesses, such as fixed based operators, or FBOs, aircraft charter companies and private suppliers, at 25 airports in California, threatens to assess significant civil penalties against the businesses if warnings, such as mailers, about the existence of lead exposure from aircraft aren’t provided to residents living near airports.
According to CEH, at seven airports drinking water sources are polluted with leaded avgas. Los Angeles International, Oakland International, John Wayne, San Diego and Long Beach airports are among the 12 airports in the country with the highest lead emissions.
Under Prop 65, the aviation businesses and fuel producers could be assessed fines of up to $2,500 per day for lead exposures, including past violations, which could lead to several millions of dollars worth of fines or more, if the CEH wins the case. Also, the law allows CEH to get a 25 percent share of the penalties if the lawsuit is upheld.
In a meeting with business aviation representatives and airport officials at Toyota AirFlite at Long Beach Airport, James Coyne, president of the National Air Transportation Association (NATA), said the CEH’s lawsuit is a form of “legal abuse,” since the suppliers of avgas are often required under lease agreements to provide the fuel to general aviation aircraft users.
Avgas fuel is currently the only fuel able to be used by general aviation aircraft users, and until an alternative form of fuel is found, which is currently underway at the federal level, aviation businesses have their hands tied, he said. The industry doesn’t anticipate a working alternative to avgas until about 2020, Coyne said.
The NATA, which represents some 2,000 aviation business organizations nationwide, is currently taking on the case on behalf of the defendants. The NATA took the case to federal court last year, declaring that federal law preempts Prop 65. However, a federal judge threw out the case since the defendants couldn’t prove industry damages yet.
The NATA also requested the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) send a letter to California’s attorney general in defense of federal regulations. However, the FAA has so far declined to take any action on behalf of the NATA due to the current political climate in Washington, D.C. A settlement is currently being negotiated by the CEH, which would get a percentage of the award and paid legal fees. However, the outcome of the settlement, expected in the next six months, would largely determine legal standing for both parties if the case goes back to federal court, and the potential for any future lawsuits, Coyne said.
“We really got to get the message out to the business community . . . that aviation in California is facing a threat that exists nowhere else in America today,” he said. “We have the State of California, individually, all by itself, deciding how dangerous aviation fuels are or not and imposing the threat of very, very significant mitigation which may lead to the abandonment of fuel for piston-aircraft if worse comes to worse.”
In an industry that has already been heavily impacted by the down economy, the lawsuit most likely has already had an impact on aircraft sales and values in California since potential buyers wouldn’t want to buy an airplane if they can’t purchase the fuel, Coyne said.
Curt Castagna, president and CEO of Long Beach-based Aeroplex Aerolease Group, said aircraft users, such as pilots and airplane owners, would be greatly impacted if the litigation goes forward, even though they aren’t directly tied to the lawsuit. “From my perspective, there’s a clear disconnect between what the FBOs are challenged with, the defendant and the end users, which some may have this perception that it’s not an issue and it’s not impacting them,” he said. “I don’t think the majority of pilots in California have a clear understanding of the real threat that exists.”
Charles Margulis, spokesperson for CEH, told the Business Journal that the goal of the litigation is to push for a speedier process of finding an alternative to avgas and reducing lead pollution nationwide.
“Will this have a big impact on the industry? Well, we hope that it has such a big impact that it will reduce lead pollution while [aviation businesses] can maintain their fleets,” he said. “That’s why we brought the lawsuit: to encourage those efforts to go forward as quickly as possible so people aren’t polluted anymore.”
The Latest News
- 2013 Aquarium of the Pacific 15th Anniversary Publication
- Long Beach Councilmembers Vote To Sue Over Railway Project
- Commercial Real Estate Council Annual Luncheon June 6
- Post Office Assures Service Standards At Long Beach Mail Processing Facility Will Remain High
- Airport Reps: City College Did Not Reach Out Prior To Cutting Aviation Program
- Governor May Use Carbon Auction Monies As Loan To General Fund
- Long Beach Fire Department To Move Forward With Training For ‘Rapid Medic Deployment’ Pilot Program
- Community Meeting May 22 For Draft Mobility Element
- Long Beach Medical Marijuana Advocates Continue Effort To Repeal City Ban Despite State High Court Ruling
Search Our Archives
|Monday Morning Coffee - 5/20/13|
Morning Coffee - A Caffeinated News Update
May 20, 2013
New Issues Of The Long Beach Business Journal Hit Stands Tomorrow:
• Copies are at the office today! Feel free to stop by and pick one up. We're located at 2599 E. 28th St., Ste. 212 in Signal Hill. We open at 8:30 a.m.
City Meetings And Events:
• May 20: Vice Mayor Robert Garcia, in conjunction with the City of Long Beach, hosts a final community meeting on the Armory Park project from 6-7:30 p.m. at the Pacific Island Ethnic Art Museum, 695 Alamitos Ave.
• May 20: Councilmember Gerrie Shipske hosts “Open Up Long Beach” from 6-8 p.m. at the Long Beach Police Officer Association Park, 7390 E. Carson St. The event is a behind the scenes look at Long Beach Police Department’s K-9 Unit. For more information, visit http://www.openuplongbeach.com or call 562/570-6932.
• May 21: The Long Beach City Council’s Long Beach Transportation and Infrastructure Committee meets at 3 p.m. at city hall to discuss: a citywide Pavement Management System; alternative sidewalk maintenance techniques; and more. Visit http://longbeach.legistar.com.
• May 21: Long Beach City Council meets at 5 p.m. at city hall to discuss: $2.1 million in contracts for grounds maintenance services; $1.1 million in contracts for service providers to operate Pacific Gateway Workforce Investment Act Youth Academy projects; and more. Visit http://longbeach.legistar.com.
• May 22: A community meeting for the Long Beach Draft Mobility Element, which is currently in the public comment period, is scheduled for 6 p.m. at the Miller Family Health Education Center, 3820 Cherry Ave. Visit http://www.lbds.info.
• May 23: Signal Hill Chamber of Commerce holds its monthly luncheon from 11:45 a.m.-1:30 p.m. at the Signal Hill Community Center, 1780 E. Hill St. $25. RSVP to Judie Johnson at firstname.lastname@example.org.
• May 23: The Long Beach Sustainable City Commission meets at 4 p.m. at city hall to discuss: the Los Cerritos Wetland Conceptual Restoration Plans; Port of Long Beach Climate Change Adaption and Coastal Resiliency Plan; and more. Visit http://longbeach.legistar.com.
• May 29: 7th District Councilmember James Johnson, in conjunction with the city’s police and fire departments, hosts a public safety summit at 7 p.m. at Silverado Park, 1545 W. 31st St., featuring Fire Chief Mike DuRee and Police Chief Jim McDonnell. Call 562/570-7777 or e-mail email@example.com.
• May 30: Temple Israel hosts a new speaker series, “Future Focus,” with inaugural speaker Mayor Bob Foster. The program is at 7:30 p.m. at Temple Israel, 269 Loma Ave. For reservations, e-mail firstname.lastname@example.org.
Business Meetings & Events:
• May 20: Wrigley Area Neighborhood Alliance meets from 7-9 p.m. at Veterans Park Social Hall, 101 E. 28th St. Guest Speaker is Ted Stevens of the city’s Animal Care Services. For more information, e-mail email@example.com or call Maria at 562/427-5021.
• May 22: East Spring Street Business Association meets from 6:15-7 p.m. at Joan Stiehl’s Farmers Insurance Office, 6200 E. Spring St., Ste. B.
• May 23: Long Beach Lincoln Club hosts a luncheon at noon at the Long Beach Yacht Club, 6201 E. Appian Way. Guest speaker is Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Philip Mautino. $25 for members; $35 for non-members. For more information call 562/439-9390.
• May 23: Long Beach Area Republican Party hosts its annual Western Bar-B-Q from 6-8 p.m. at El Dorado Golf Course, 2400 N. Studebaker Rd. Speaker is Ruben Barrales, former director of White House Intergovernmental Affairs and current president of “Grow-Elect,” an organization to help elect Republican Latino candidates to public office. $50. RSVP to 562/424-1246 or visit http://www.longbeachrepublicans.org.
• May 27: Forest Lawn celebrates Memorial Day with its annual program at 10 a.m. at 1500 E. San Antonio Dr.
• May 28: East Anaheim Street Business Alliance hosts its monthly business meeting at noon at the Long Beach Playhouse, 5021 E. Anaheim St. Featured guest speaker is Straight Talk TV host Art Levine. Lunch is optional. RSVP at firstname.lastname@example.org or 562/494-3800